Day- 10 Overview
I can't believe that I am actually caught up on my blogs today. I did two. One early this morning and one now. Two excellent meetings. The meeting with the Chief was another inspiring one. I am just humbled by the talent of the people here in providing developmental solutions. The Chief's shop is one that should be looked at and replicated. It rained today (YEA!!) the farmers really needed that, even though it was short and late. But it kept me in town and we weren't able to get out to the farms. But I got out this second blog instead, and got to eat some local cuisine. Guinea Fowl in Groundnut Soup (tasted a bit like a peanut sauce that was spicy). Was also able to find some more research I couldn't locate in the states. (Google sometimes needs a little more detail and I got that detail here.) If you didn't catch blog Day 9, check the archive. It was a good one.
:-)
I added a driving through town scene. Motorbikes are very prevalent here in the north, especially here in Tamale.
Day 10- Tamale Ministry of Agriculture
We met with the Ministry of Agriculture in Tamale. We met with the Northern Regional Director of Ministry of Food and Agriculture. After we described the project he then brought in his entire team of employees. I took that as a good sign. We asked him first about the percentages of people who actually do farming for a living (i have heard and seen different percentages). He said it varies by region. Could be as high as 70 percent in northern regions, but as low as 40 percent in some southern regions.
We described our mission and potential rainfall insurance product to see if there was a need. He said that there is a huge need for such a product because the issue is that the farmers can’t enough capital to make significant improvements because agriculture is so risky. The banks and microfinancial institutions can't have too a large a part of their portfolio in agriculture (which we learned from info. in previous blogs). He thinks that a product that would help reduce the variability of loss would give them more incentive to provide loans to farmers.
We met with the Ministry of Agriculture in Tamale. We met with the Northern Regional Director of Ministry of Food and Agriculture. After we described the project he then brought in his entire team of employees. I took that as a good sign. We asked him first about the percentages of people who actually do farming for a living (i have heard and seen different percentages). He said it varies by region. Could be as high as 70 percent in northern regions, but as low as 40 percent in some southern regions.
We described our mission and potential rainfall insurance product to see if there was a need. He said that there is a huge need for such a product because the issue is that the farmers can’t enough capital to make significant improvements because agriculture is so risky. The banks and microfinancial institutions can't have too a large a part of their portfolio in agriculture (which we learned from info. in previous blogs). He thinks that a product that would help reduce the variability of loss would give them more incentive to provide loans to farmers.
At a small level he didn’t see a need for a rainfall insurance product. For those farmers the preferred risk management tool is crop diversification. However, some of the farmers that are growing mono crop cash crops (like rice) might be interested. They are usually more sophisticated. Might be rolled out to informal group of farmers. Might also be a need for farmers who have livestock.
There are informal “insurance” mechanisms. They gave an example of a project sponsored by (Millenium Development Authority) (MiDA) where they provided input and then the farmers agreed to contribute one bag of maize for every acre they have. This goes to a common fund to help pay for group members who suffer a loss.
They suggested other partners that might be interested such a product be Assoc. of Church Development Project and the Stambick(sp?) Bank (S.A. Bank). Maybe companies who rely on cocoa producers too?
Consequences of crop loss
This is a question we have posed to everyone. Here are his thoughts.
Depends on the severity what the consequences are:
Example:
Depends on the severity what the consequences are:
Example:
Severe
· Girls runaway from home.
· Families pack up and travel.
· Girls runaway from home.
· Families pack up and travel.
Intermediate
· Will sell their labor to other farmers at below market rate.
· If all else fails the sell off animals in the following order, goods (chickens and guinea fowl), then goats, then sheep, then cattle. If you see farmers selling cattle for food it indicates that it is catastrophic for the farmer. (There is probably an economic index in their somewhere).
We presented two options of insurance. The Rainfall Insurance Product for more sophisticated buyer who understands the trigger and who it works. Then possibly a different product for small farmers (which I went into some detail to explain) and they thought that both sounded like they would be accepted in the market once.
· Will sell their labor to other farmers at below market rate.
· If all else fails the sell off animals in the following order, goods (chickens and guinea fowl), then goats, then sheep, then cattle. If you see farmers selling cattle for food it indicates that it is catastrophic for the farmer. (There is probably an economic index in their somewhere).
We presented two options of insurance. The Rainfall Insurance Product for more sophisticated buyer who understands the trigger and who it works. Then possibly a different product for small farmers (which I went into some detail to explain) and they thought that both sounded like they would be accepted in the market once.
We then met a group of Indian consultants from OLAM
OLAM Nigeria Lmtd.
They are looking to bring Rice production services to Ghana. They partner with banks, NGOs, and US AID. They won a U.N. World Bank Business Award. One of his concerns about Ghana is the lack of crop insurance. Unlike in Nigeria where they have crop insurance. The insurance is multirisk. It is for only registered coops in Nigeria. It is 5% premium. For $600 of inputs for rice the premium would be $30. But the farmer only pays 2% of the 5%. Or in this example $12. The state and federal pay the rest of the premium because they benefit from the farmers getting insurance.
The multiperil risk is rainfall (drought and flood), birds, pests, and disease. Although the general manager suggested that rainfall (drought or flood) is really the most important part of the product.
The multiperil risk is rainfall (drought and flood), birds, pests, and disease. Although the general manager suggested that rainfall (drought or flood) is really the most important part of the product.
According to the Managing Director of OLAM, last year the insurance paid out $180,000 for 50,000 acres. This is the Nigerian Agricultural Insurance is part of Nigerian Government and was in conjunction with US AID. The payout this year was $220,000. Will have to check out what that is in terms of the premium they collected.
Meeting the Chief
Met with Nana (Chief) Yusif Abdulai. He is the Managing Director of the Northern Rural Development Bank an Association of Financial NGO’s. They do Microfinance ++. They have been around since 1997. The + includes education on financial literacy, health (HIV/AIDS,maternal health, Malaria,), technical crop assistance for farmers associations. They have 4500 men and women who have Susu accounts. They make loans strictly to women ranging from GHc100 ($75)to GHc 1000. Like most vendor loans we have seen, theirs are four month loans. This was the longest running and most well-organized of all that we have met so far. Really well designed and executed.
They loan to vendors, farm producers and processors, hair dressers,etc. Their process is to form solidarity groups into associations. Then they require education (financial literacy, record keeping, health, etc) of 6 weeks before they give the loan . This education helps the women succeed in their businesses and thus be more reliable creditors. All loans are given to an association of women. An association is comprised of 30 women with five solidarity groups. The way it works is that the solidarity group first guarantees the loans for each of its members and then if the group can’t pay all the loan, the association must step in to pay. (They do have a contingency in case there is an association default risk. They measure success not only in terms of repayment but also in terms of women who grow their business to the point that they can get a bank loan and then become a part of the formal financial sector.
Met with Nana (Chief) Yusif Abdulai. He is the Managing Director of the Northern Rural Development Bank an Association of Financial NGO’s. They do Microfinance ++. They have been around since 1997. The + includes education on financial literacy, health (HIV/AIDS,maternal health, Malaria,), technical crop assistance for farmers associations. They have 4500 men and women who have Susu accounts. They make loans strictly to women ranging from GHc100 ($75)to GHc 1000. Like most vendor loans we have seen, theirs are four month loans. This was the longest running and most well-organized of all that we have met so far. Really well designed and executed.
They loan to vendors, farm producers and processors, hair dressers,etc. Their process is to form solidarity groups into associations. Then they require education (financial literacy, record keeping, health, etc) of 6 weeks before they give the loan . This education helps the women succeed in their businesses and thus be more reliable creditors. All loans are given to an association of women. An association is comprised of 30 women with five solidarity groups. The way it works is that the solidarity group first guarantees the loans for each of its members and then if the group can’t pay all the loan, the association must step in to pay. (They do have a contingency in case there is an association default risk. They measure success not only in terms of repayment but also in terms of women who grow their business to the point that they can get a bank loan and then become a part of the formal financial sector.
One of the innovations that the Northern Rural Bank has undertaken is to provide a storage facility for farmers to store their crops immediately after harvest because the price they can get at harvest is very low in comparison (about Ghc18 for a bag of maize to a price of Ghc60 if they hold on to it for a few months.) They give the farmer an advance on their loan which represents the market rate at harvest time. (This would be all the many farmers would get). However by storing the grain until mid season when the prices go up more than four times they can just use that difference to pay off the loan. The Chief learned this from Boulder Microfinance Institute Workshop he attended in Italy.
They see a need for an insurance product for property loss (fire and theft) for their market vendors. It needs to be set up well, designed in terms they understand, and then provided with a great deal of education. We discussed what that might look like and he like the design.
The education that they provide is for financial literacy, health (malaria, diarrhea, HIV/AID).
However, they have one hugely value-added for their farmers, something we have heard before a need for (We heard that need expressed here at our meeting in Sunyani.) but until now, have not heard of a financial institution providing- That is weather information. They give weather information to farmers during their weekly meetings. This helps their farmers to plant at the right time. We heard that from several people one problem farmers have is that they don’t get the tv or radio weather forecasts. So they are planting based on previous timetables, which may not apply under current climatic conditions.
They have a history of working with volunteers and study abroad students.(Max of three at one time). The typical stint is for 2-3 weeks. The students stay with host families in Tamale.They then go out and do the training at the Susu meetings. He said that they can provide the content (although they do have materials from Microfinance Opportunities (a D.C. organization I visited a year ago) but they said the advantage the students have is that they draw a crowd and people listen. Given the topics that they would like to have covered it might be good to have a multidisciplinary mixed team of Agriculture,Nursing, and Business students even if they provide content for the training materials.
Here are some phrase words I have picked up that may help you navigate around:
Greeting in morning (da-si-ba) Response: n.naa
Afternoon greeting (n.tiray) Response n.naa
Evening greeting (annuwula) Response n.naa
How are you? (Kawula) Response Alaafay (or al-off-ee) I’m doing fine
Thank you (em-Poo-Hair)
Greeting in morning (da-si-ba) Response: n.naa
Afternoon greeting (n.tiray) Response n.naa
Evening greeting (annuwula) Response n.naa
How are you? (Kawula) Response Alaafay (or al-off-ee) I’m doing fine
Thank you (em-Poo-Hair)
Faithfully submitted,
Jim Jones
Director-Katie School of Insurance
Illinois State University
Jim Jones
Director-Katie School of Insurance
Illinois State University
No comments:
Post a Comment